Differing Moods of Investors and Consumers

Differing Moods of Investors and Consumers

Weekly BriefApril 01, 2026•7 min read

Before the war with Iran, both investors and consumers were already facing significant uncertainty about the outlook for their finances and the broader U.S. economy. Investors were focused on several key issues, including the future path of Federal Reserve interest rates, the appointment of a new Federal Reserve Chair, rising inflation, and the potential effects of tariffs.

Consumers, meanwhile, had their own set of concerns. These included persistently high mortgage rates, a sluggish housing market, the rising cost of living, and worries about job security, particularly considering increasing AI-related disruption.

However, consumers are experiencing a greater level of anxiety than business owners. The University of Michigan’s Consumer Sentiment Index fell to 53.3 in March 2026, down from a preliminary reading of 55.5 and below February’s 56.6.

Joanne Hsu, Surveys of Consumers Director, provided this commentary:

Ms. Hsu noted that this month’s sentiment reading is the lowest since December 2025. However, looking at the data going back to 1953, consumer sentiment has rarely been this depressed and is now dropping to historic lows, only previously reached in April 1980 and during the summer of 2022.

Since February 2020, consumer sentiment has declined sharply, and rebounds have been unusually brief, typically followed by further drops to new lows.

The war has added more uncertainty for both investors and consumers. However, again, consumer sentiment declined at a greater rate than business sentiment. We wrote in our February 11, 2026, update that.

So far, U.S. businesses and consumers have largely remained on the sidelines, with global events having minimal direct impact. Supply chains for most essential goods have stayed intact, and gasoline prices have remained relatively stable—aside from California, where price pressures are driven by factors unrelated to the war. This stability is largely due to the U.S. aggressive expansion in oil and gas production during the past decade, which led the country to become a net exporter of oil and natural gas for the first time in decades in 2019.

Today, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) released its Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS). In February, hiring and layoffs showed little change, and there was also no significant movement in quits or discharges. The BLS noted the following:

One explanation for the stable number of job openings is the slowing activity of new hires, discharges, and quits. The BLS noted in this month’s report the following:

Looking at this data going back to 2000, the pre-pandemic peak in job openings occurred in January 2019 at 7.5 million, compared to 6.882 million in February. The lowest level was recorded in July 2009, when job openings fell to just 2.23 million.

Despite ongoing concerns about layoffs, rising unemployment, and a decline in job availability, the U.S. economy and business environment remain stable and, by historical standards over the past two decades, could be viewed as relatively robust.

Institutional investors and analysts are expressing concern about contagion with the Iran war impacting supply chains and business growth.

While institutional investors and analysts express concerns about war and domestic issues, the slow net selling of stocks year to date would indicate their much lower level of anxiety. My interpretation of their trading activity is more a concern of FOMO (fear of missing out) than the risks of a continuing selloff. Below is a YTD chart of the major indices. Note the continued leadership of small, mid-cap, and international indices over former leaders of the SP 500 and NASDAQ.

What Does This Mean to Me?

Since early February, we have been increasing cash positions in our Growth and Growth & Income model portfolios. We have not made significant changes to our Income and Balanced portfolios, as they already maintain higher allocations to guaranteed high-yield money market funds and investment-grade bonds.

Within the Growth and Growth & Income models, we began trimming underperforming positions in early February, directing proceeds into cash. As market declines accelerated, we continued this process, bringing cash allocations to approximately 20%. We anticipate a modest rebound in equities and a decline in Treasury yields once a meaningful resolution with Iran is achieved. That may be an opportunity to reinvest the cash allocation in equities.

Today, U.S. equities are experiencing a relief rally driven by optimism around a near-term resolution to the conflict and the potential reopening of the Strait of Hormuz. However, this optimism may prove short-lived, as the rally appears to be based largely on rumors and unofficial commentary from both Washington and Iran. The Strait remains closed, and crude oil prices continue to hover near multi-year highs.

Bloomberg reported today that Iran struck a fully loaded Kuwaiti oil tanker in Dubai waters, raising further uncertainty about Iran’s long-term economic strategy with its Middle Eastern neighbors. Brent crude rose approximately 5% to $118 per barrel, while U.S.-based West Texas Intermediate (WTI) increased about 1% to $101 per barrel.

Our outlook on the U.S. economy and equity markets remains modestly positive. We expect a meaningful rebound in stocks following a sustainable resolution to the Iran conflict and the reopening of the Strait. However, we anticipate that markets may gradually weaken thereafter as attention shifts back to underlying economic challenges. A key variable will be the normalization of energy prices. Historically, CEOs raise prices in increments of dollars with the onset of risks and lower them in increments of pennies as risks are mitigated. It may take several months or longer before retail gasoline prices return to pre-war levels.

This slow realignment of prices may extend across many industries, as business leaders maintain elevated pricing to recover prior profit losses. Unfortunately, higher prices such as the now-common $20 breakfast may persist.

Institutional investors will be closely watching upcoming earnings reports and forward guidance to shape portfolio strategy. From yesterday’s close, the S&P 500 and NASDAQ would need to rally approximately 10% to 16%, respectively, to achieve a 6% gain for the year. While attainable, such gains are unlikely if the war conflict extends through the summer.

We welcome your thoughts on this update. Please feel free to reach out with any questions regarding your investment accounts or financial planning. We look forward to helping you and your family achieve your financial goals.

blog author image

Anton Bayer

Back to Blog